Acne scars.
It's a cruel joke after enduring years and years of acne.
Trust me, I know how that feels.
I've struggled with acne for most of my life and still have scars to this day.
That's why I created this definitive guide on acne scars.
I'll show you how to get rid of acne scars using the latest medical research and clinical studies.
Let's beat acne scars together!
Are you ready to get started?
Table of Contents
First, we need to learn more about acne scars.
In this chapter, I'll explain:
Acne scars are essentially damaged skin left behind by inflammatory acne.
They come in many shapes and sizes, from pitted to indented to raised scars.
In short, acne scars are caused by chronic inflammation.
What do I mean by this?
You might recall that acne is an inflammatory skin disease, characterized by:
Every time you get a pimple, it means that P. acnes, a naturally occurring bacteria in your skin, has grown out-of-control.
The bacteria feeds on excess sebum in your hair follicle and multiplies in numbers.
This damages the surrounding skin and triggers an inflammatory response.
Normally, inflammation is a good thing.
It puts your immune system on high alert, induces blood clotting, and activates wound healing processes to repair injured skin. (1)
Unfortunately, inflammation only exacerbates the problem with acne.
It weakens your hair follicle and allows P. acnes to spread to neighboring skin tissue.
This causes further cell damage and sets off a vicious cycle of injury-inflammation.
If left unchecked, inflammation will severely damage your skin.
That's why chronic inflammation is responsible for most acne scars.
You'll see how this works as we walk through the different stages of acne.
Stage 1: Microcomedone
The perfect storm of excess keratin and sebum (thanks to hormonal changes during puberty) causes dead skin cells to stick together.
This results in the dreaded "clogged pore".
Keratin is a tough protein found in skin cells that provides your skin's protective properties.
Sebum is an oily substance produced by the sebaceous gland. It has lubricating and hydrating properties that help maintain your skin's acid mantle.
Stage 2: Whitehead / Blackhead (Pimples)
Unable to leave, the mixture of keratin, sebum, and dead skin cells create a "bulge" in the hair follicle. This is called a whitehead (closed pore) or blackhead (open pore).
To make matters worse, P. acnes feeds on the excess sebum and grows out-of-control.
Stage 3: Papule / Pustule (Severe Acne)
As P. acnes continues to multiply, it triggers an inflammatory response.
Your immune system intervenes by dispatching white blood cells to the area.
Unfortunately, these white blood cells are unable to control P. acnes growth.
Instead, they get stuck in the sticky mixture of sebum, keratin, dead skin cells, and P. acnes (colloquially known as "pus").
This combination is highly inflammatory.
It weakens the walls of the hair follicle and spills into the adjacent skin tissue.
This causes further cell damage and continues a vicious cycle of injury-inflammation.
Stage 4: Cyst / Nodule (Very Severe Acne)
By this point, chronic inflammation and P. acnes expansion has completely destroyed the hair follicle and most of the surrounding skin tissue.
Important components of the skin such as collagen have also been compromised.
This type of deep cystic acne is what causes acne scars.
CHAPTER 2:
We're all different in our own ways.
You might like cats, while I prefer dogs.
The same is true of acne scars.
You might have lots of atrophic scars, while I tend to get hypertrophic scars and keloids.
It depends on how our body heals itself.
In this chapter, we'll look at the different types of acne scars and how to identify each one.
First, there tends to be a lot of confusion between acne scars and acne marks.
Many people who think they have acne scars actually have acne marks.
Acne Scars
Acne scars are changes in skin texture caused by the loss of collagen (atrophic scars) or excessive amount of collagen (raised scars).
Unfortunately, acne scars do not go away on their own.
Acne Marks
On the other hand, acne marks are changes in skin color caused by excess melanin (hyperpigmentation) or chronic inflammation (erythema).
Fortunately, acne marks often resolve themselves and are easier to treat than acne scars.
Atrophic scars are "pitted" depressions in the skin caused by the loss of collagen. (2)
You tend to get these scars where deep cystic acne has lingered for a long time.
Chapter 3 covers general treatments for atrophic scars.
Chapter 4 covers treatments specific to ice pick scars.
Chapter 5 covers treatments specific to boxcar scars and rolling scars.
You might also have tethered scars.
This means there are fibrous bands between the base of the scar and the underlying tissue.
These bands "pull" on the scar and create the appearance of depressions or indentations.
Raised scars are elevated bands of scar tissue caused by excessive collagen growth. (3)
They are thick, lumpy, and may appear shiny. These scars are usually red to pink.
Research also suggests there's a genetic component to raised scars, especially keloids.
Chapter 6 covers treatments for hypertrophic scars and keloids.
We often get dark spots as well after acne.
Thankfully, this is not an acne scar and will usually go away by itself.
Also known as hyperpigmentation, these brown spots are caused by excess melanin.
Melanin is an important pigment in your skin. It determines your skin color and protects your skin from the sun's UV rays.
Chapter 7 discusses common treatments for hyperpigmentation.
CHAPTER 3:
If your acne scars are pitted, indented, or "saucer-like", you probably have atrophic scars.
These are the most common types of acne scars, and include ice pick scars, boxcar scars, and rolling scars.
Atrophic scars are caused by inflammatory damage from chronic and/or severe acne.
Fortunately, these treatments may help:
For additional options, see chapters 4 and 5.
Chemical peels are a popular and affordable option for acne scar treatment.
The most common peels include alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs) like glycolic acid and lactic acid.
How It Works
Chemical peels cause a mild exfoliation of the epidermis to mid-dermis. It helps "unglue" the bonds between dead skin cells and allows them to naturally slough off. (4)
This helps smooth uneven skin texture and reduce the appearance of atrophic scars.
Chemical peels also trigger inflammation and stimulate collagen production. (4)
This can help "fill in" the pits and depressions left behind by severe acne.
Following a chemical peel, your skin should appear brighter and more even looking.
Don't forget to use sunscreen after a chemical peel!
RELATED:
Types of Chemical Peels
There are many types of chemical peels:
Your dermatologist or esthetician will determine which peels are suitable for you based on your skin type, degree of scarring, and medical history.
About the Procedure
Chemical peels are quick and easy. They can be done by your dermatologist or at home.
Side effects include redness, itchiness, and for stronger peels, flaking and peeling.
Make sure to follow these general safety tips:
Cost of Chemical Peels
According to Healthline, prices range from $150 for light peels to over $3,000 for deep peels.
Verdict
Chemical peels are a tried-and-true option for acne scars and hyperpigmentation.
PROS
CONS
Introduced in the 1950s, dermabrasion is one of the earliest acne scar treatments.
These days, it's used more for deep wrinkles, sun damage, and pigmentation disorders.
How It Works
Dermabrasion "buffs" away entire layers of skin with a rapidly rotating abrasive tip. (5)
The tip can be a serrated metal wheel, diamond tip, or wire brush.
This facial resurfacing technique triggers inflammation and wound healing signals that encourage collagen remodeling.
In particular, it may help plump up the appearance of boxcar scars.
Here's a demonstration of dermabrasion by Dr. Leif Rogers (before and after results here).
About the Procedure
Dermabrasion takes anywhere from a few minutes for smaller areas to 1-2 hours for larger areas to complete.
Your dermatologist will inject a local anesthetic to limit the pain.
Following the procedure, your skin may feel tender, swollen, and appear red or pink. New skin usually takes 7-10 days to form. Unfortunately, the pinkness can last for several weeks. (6)
Contraindications
Dermabrasion is not suitable for everyone, particularly those who:
Given the long recovery time, number of side effects, and high dependency on operator skill, dermabrasion has been largely replaced by laser treatments (covered in Chapter 5).
Cost of Dermabrasion
According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, the average cost of dermabrasion was $1,170 in 2017.
Verdict
Dermabrasion can be effective but has mostly been replaced by laser resurfacing.
PROS
CONS
Microdermabrasion is a milder version of dermabrasion with fewer side effects.
This treatment is widely available at salons, spas, and dermatologist offices.
How It Works
Instead of an abrasive tip, microdermabrasion uses fine particles of aluminum oxide or sodium bicarbonate to achieve the same exfoliating effect.
These fine particles are blown onto your face, brushing away dead skin cells, and then immediately sucked back into the machine through a vacuum.
Here's a demonstration of microdermabrasion by Anahi Leal.
About the Procedure
Since the effects are less pronounced, multiple sessions are generally required.
What's nice though is the convenience and affordability of this treatment.
And if you're a frequent user, you can save a lot of money by investing in a personal microdermabrasion machine to use at home.
Verdict
Microdermabrasion is a convenient and affordable option for mild atrophic scars.
PROS
CONS
Filler injections are commonly used for wrinkles and fine lines.
More recently, however, dermatologists have started using fillers for acne scars. (7)
How It Works
Fillers are injected into the scar to encourage revolumization of skin tissue.
This raises the skin surface and reduces the appearance of pitted and indented scars.
Common fillers include:
Fillers are usually temporary and require periodic "top-ups" to maintain results.
Here's a quick video that explains how fillers work by Dr. Davin Lim.
Types of Dermal Fillers
There are many types and brands of dermal fillers. You'll want to consider:
Hyaluronic Acid (HA)
HA is a temporary filler that lasts up to 18 months.
Hyaluronic acid is one of the most abundant materials in the skin's extracellular matrix. It serves many functions including wound healing, skin regeneration, and hydration.
Studies on HA fillers show improvements in scar appearance with minimal side effects. (7)
Brand names include:
Poly L-Lactic Acid (PLLA)
PLLA is a semi-permanent filler that lasts up to 2 years.
It's made of synthetic biodegradable polymer and can stimulate collagen growth within a few weeks of the injection.
Studies on PLLA and acne scarring have all shown positive results. (7)
A study in 2014 also examined PLLA injections following ablative CO2 laser treatment. The authors noted that 95% of scars showed improvement after 3 months. (8)
Brand names include Sculptra.
Calcium Hydroxylapatite (CA)
CA is a semi-permanent filler that lasts up to 18 months.
It's made from natural substances found in bones and teeth and can create significant volume in a short period of time.
There is only one study on CA and acne scars with a small sample size (10 participants). (9)
Brand names include Radiesse.
Polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)
PMMA is a tongue-twister of a filler that is specifically FDA-approved for acne scars. (7)
It's a synthetic and biocompatible filler that can produce long-lasting results (>3 years).
Brand names include Bellafill (previously called Artefill).
About the Procedure
A filler injection is usually a quick visit with your dermatologist.
Side effects may include mild pain, discomfort, and redness.
Cost of Dermal Fillers
According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, the average price of fillers were:
Verdict
Dermal fillers are a relatively new technique for treating atrophic scars.
PROS
CONS
CHAPTER 4:
If your acne scars resemble small puncture marks, you likely have ice pick scars.
These are caused by deep cystic acne, such as a large cyst or nodule.
Use these effective treatments to get rid of ice pick scars for good:
TCA CROSS (“Chemical Reconstruction of Skin Scars”) is a simple and effective procedure for removing ice pick scars.
How It Works
It involves applying a high concentration of trichloroacetic acid (TCA), typically 70-100%, with a wooden toothpick to the base of the ice pick scar.
This burns away problematic scar tissue and triggers wound healing signals.
Collagen growth and tissue repair follows to help "fill in" the scar cavities.
The result is smoother skin and less noticeable acne scarring.
Here's an excellent video on TCA CROSS by Dr. Davin Lim.
Clinical Evidence
On average, studies have shown a 25% improvement in scar appearance after one session of TCA CROSS. Most people will need 3-6 sessions every 2 to 8 weeks. (5)
About the Procedure
During the treatment, it's perfectly normal to see a white frost appear. This will subside in a few hours and indicates the depth of TCA penetration.
Cost of TCA CROSS
According to Dr. Davin Lim, TCA CROSS costs between $1,000 to $1,400 per session.
Verdict
TCA CROSS is a simple and effective treatment for ice pick scars.
PROS
CONS
If TCA CROSS was unsuccessful, you may want to consider surgical options such as punch excision. It's considered one of the best treatments for ice pick scars. (5)
How It Works
Your dermatologist or plastic surgeon will use a "punch tool" (the same one used for biopsies) to remove the ice pick scar.
Afterwards, they'll stitch up the wound with sutures or steri-strips.
Following surgery, collagen fibers form new skin tissue in place of the ice pick scar.
Keep in mind that this still leaves behind a small scar. For this reason, punch excision is often paired with laser therapy to remove residual scarring.
Here's a demonstration of punch excision by Dr. Jason Emer.
Cost of Punch Excision
According to RealSelf, punch excision may cost upwards of $1,000 per session.
Verdict
Punch excision is an effective surgical treatment for ice pick scars.
PROS
CONS
Punch grafting is an alternative technique for ice pick scars. (5)
How It Works
Similar to punch excision, a small tool is used to remove the scar. But instead of closing the wound, a skin graft (usually taken from behind the ear) is inserted.
The idea is for the skin graft to plug the hole and connect itself to the surrounding skin.
This makes the ice pick scar less noticeable.
Since grafts are taken from another part of your body, there's always a risk of texture and color mismatch with the original scar.
While highly effective, the procedure is also quite painstaking – up to 20 or more replacement grafts may be required in a single session (ouch!).
Cost of Punch Grafting
According to RealSelf, punch grafting may cost between $250 to $750 per scar.
Verdict
Punch grafting is an alternative surgical option for difficult ice pick scars.
PROS
CONS
CHAPTER 5:
Boxcar scars are indentations that look like a fingernail was pushed into your skin.
Rolling scars are continuous depressions that look like waves or ripples.
Both are caused when inflammatory acne has spread to the surrounding skin.
Try the following treatments to banish both types of acne scars!
Microneedling is a simple and effective treatment for both boxcar and rolling scars.
This procedure is also known as skin needling or collagen induction therapy.
How It Works
Microneedling involves using a small handheld tool with ultra fine needles (derma roller or microneedling pen) to "punch" tiny holes into your skin.
This triggers inflammation and wound healing signals that stimulate collagen growth. Over time, new skin tissue "fills in" the old scar margins.
The result is smoother skin and an overall improvement in scar appearance.
Microneedling is particularly well-suited for darker skin tones due to the lower risk of hyperpigmentation compared to treatments like laser resurfacing. (10)
Clinical Evidence
Between 2011 and 2016, over 10 studies evaluated the effectiveness of microneedling. Most of these found microneedling was effective on its own or in combination with scar treatments like chemical peels and subcision. (10)
In particular, one study in 2014 of 30 patients noted that microneedling produced an average improvement of 50-75% on a scar assessment scale. (11)
About the Procedure
Before getting started, your dermatologist will apply a numbing cream or spray to help ease the pain and discomfort.
A recovery serum such as hyaluronic acid is also applied to lubricate the skin and encourage collagen formation after the treatment.
Microneedling is generally well-tolerated and requires no downtime. Redness and swelling should subside in 2-3 days.
Initial results are usually seen within 6 weeks with full results after 3 months. (5)
Skin texture may continue to improve over 12 months as new collagen is deposited.
Microneedling with PRP ("Vampire Facial")
Thanks to Kim Kardashian, the "vampire facial" has grown rapidly in popularity.
The actual procedure is called microneedling with platelet-rich plasma (PRP) and involves using your own blood as the recovery serum!
Before the treatment, a syringe of blood is taken from you and put through a centrifuge machine to separate the PRP from red blood cells.
But why put blood on your face?
As it turns out, PRP contains an abundance of growth factors essential for collagen formation.
By applying PRP directly, you can jump-start the recovery process and obtain better results from microneedling.
Maybe that's why vampires never age?
Here's a video demonstration of microneedling with PRP.
Cost of Microneedling
Standard microneedling costs anywhere from $200 to $700 per session. Keep in mind that most people will need 3-6 sessions for best results.
Microneedling with PRP will set you back around $750 per session.
Verdict
Microneedling is a simple and effective treatment for stimulating collagen growth.
PROS
CONS
Subcision is short for subcutaneous incisionless surgery.
It's considered the gold standard for removing tethered scars.
Boxcar scars and rolling scars are often held down by fibrous bands of scar tissue between the base of the scar and the underlying tissue.
These fibrotic "tethers" create the appearance of depressions and indentations.
How It Works
Subcision aims to eliminate atrophic scars by manually breaking the fibrous bands with a special needle (such as Nokor).
Following the procedure, new collagen growth raises the skin surface back to normal.
This can greatly diminish the appearance of boxcar scars and rolling scars.
Clinical Evidence
In a 2005 study of 40 patients, subcision resulted in approximately 50% improvement in scar appearance according to both patients and investigators. (12)
About the Procedure
Subcision is a simple and well-tolerated procedure.
First, a local anesthetic is injected to manage the pain and discomfort.
Your dermatologist then inserts a special needle under your skin to break the fibrous bands. The needle is passed in multiple directions to ensure no fibrotic tethers remain.
Some minor bleeding and soreness is expected after the operation.
Here's an excellent video of subcision by Dr. Davin Lim.
Contraindications
Subcision may not be suitable for those who:
Cost of Subcision
According to RealSelf, the average cost of subcision is around $1,450 per session.
Verdict
Subcision is the gold standard for removing tethered scars.
PROS
CONS
Laser technology has been used for decades to treat all types of acne scars.
Today, fractional lasers provide excellent results with few side effects and very little downtime.
In addition, some such as the pulsed dye laser can reduce skin redness as well. (13)
How It Works
When laser energy penetrates your skin, it "vaporizes" the underlying cell tissue.
This causes targeted thermal damage in the dermis with minimal damage to the epidermis.
These wounds trigger inflammation and stimulate collagen production.
Over time, new collagen is deposited that improves the appearance of atrophic scars like boxcar scars and rolling scars.
I've included a brief overview of the different types of lasers below:
If you prefer to watch a video, here's an excellent explanation of lasers for acne scars.
Ablative Lasers
Ablative lasers are more intense as they can remove entire layers of skin. Local anesthesia or sedation is often required to reduce discomfort and pain. (14)
Ablative lasers such as the carbon dioxide (CO2) and Erbium are much more effective for acne scar treatment. (15)
That's because these lasers go deeper and trigger collagen remodeling in the dermis.
Carbon Dioxide (CO2) Laser
The CO2 laser was considered the “gold standard” of laser treatment for wrinkles, fine lines, and acne scars during the late 1990s and early 2000s. (16)
However, there were many side effects, including pain, redness, and hyperpigmentation.
This caused many practitioners to switch to the Erbium laser.
Today, CO2 lasers have been largely replaced by fractional CO2 lasers, which provide similar results with fewer complications.
Erbium (Er:YAG) Laser
The erbium yttrium aluminum garnet (Er:YAG) is a milder type of ablative laser.
In practice, however, it was found to have similar side effects as CO2 lasers. (16)
Non-Ablative Lasers
Given the issues with ablative lasers, many surgeons switched to non-ablative lasers.
These work by heating up skin tissue without damaging the actual structure.
While non-ablative lasers have fewer side effects and shorter recovery times, they are less effective than their ablative cousins.
Neodymium (Nd:YAG) Laser
The neodymium yttrium aluminum garnet (Nd:YAG) laser is often used for patients with darker or more sensitive skin.
This procedure requires more frequent sessions (3-5 times per month) but can provide long-lasting improvements.
Fractional Lasers
Fractional lasers were a breakthrough in laser technology.
These types of lasers can achieve excellent results without the unwanted side effects.
Rather than a continuous beam, the fractional laser is split into thousands of microscopic treatment zones that are treated in pulses.
This allows more skin tissue to remain intact which significantly speeds up recovery times (24 hours compared to 2 weeks for ablative lasers) and limits adverse side effects.
Fractional lasers are available in both ablative and non-ablative versions. This comes as traditional lasers have adopted the fractional technique.
For instance, the fractional CO2 laser has replaced the traditional CO2 laser.
FRAXEL is a popular brand that offers fractional ablative and non-ablative lasers.
About the Procedure
People often describe laser resurfacing as "rubber bands snapping your skin".
A local anesthetic is used to dull the pain (sedation may be required for extensive treatments).
Your dermatologist then treats the acne scars with a laser wand.
Your skin will feel tender and swollen after the treatment (and appear red). Apply an ice pack and follow your doctor's instructions for at home care.
Depending on the laser, side effects may include hypopigmentation (loss of skin color), hyperpigmentation (darker skin color), and prolonged redness. (17)
Cost of Laser Resurfacing
Laser therapy tends to be an expensive procedure. According to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, the average costs were:
Verdict
Fractional laser resurfacing can improve many types of acne scars.
PROS
CONS
Radiofrequency is a promising new treatment for atrophic scars.
Also known as microneedling fractional radiofrequency (MFR), it combines elements of microneedling, fractional laser techniques, and radiofrequency energy.
The main downside is the high cost and limited availability (the equipment can be prohibitively expensive for many dermatologists).
How It Works
A device similar to a microneedling pen is used to punch tiny holes into your skin. During each "punch", radiofrequency energy is emitted from the tips of the needles.
This causes targeted thermal damage in the dermis which triggers collagen remodeling.
The result is softer and smoother skin with less noticeable acne scarring.
Here's a demonstration of radiotherapy by Dr. Jason Emer.
Clinical Evidence
In one study, researchers evaluated the progress of 31 patients that underwent MFR for acne scar treatment. They found significant improvements after four sessions of radiofrequency spaced 6 weeks apart. (18)
About the Procedure
Your dermatologist will use a device (similar to a microneedling pen) to "stamp" areas across your face. This may require 2 full passes to cover the most surface area.
Side effects include mild pain, redness, and itchiness.
Cost of Radiofrequency
According to Fashionista, radiofrequency treatment can cost around $1,000-$2,500 per session. With multiple sessions, you could be looking at over $5,000 in costs.
It may be hard to find dermatologists that offer this treatment due to the high equipment cost.
Verdict
Radiotherapy is an expensive alternative for stubborn atrophic scars.
PROS
CONS
Finally, punch elevation is a surgical technique that works well on boxcar scars.
This procedure is similar to punch excision (used for ice pick scars).
How It Works
Your doctor will use a small "punch tool" to remove the boxcar scar.
The skin tissue is then carefully pulled up to the level of the surrounding skin and held in place with sutures or skin glue.
Punch elevation is effective because it lifts the base of the boxcar scar to match the height of the surrounding skin.
The punched tissue is essentially a skin graft in the same location.
Since the skin graft is taken from the same site, there's no risk of texture or color mismatch (as with punch grafting). (5)
Similar to other punch techniques, this treatment will leave behind a smaller scar. So you'll need further treatments like laser resurfacing to get rid of residual scars. (19)
Cost of Punch Elevation
According to LakeView Dermatology, punch elevation may cost around $100 per scar.
Verdict
Punch elevation is an alternative surgical option for boxcar scars.
PROS
CONS
CHAPTER 6:
If your acne scars are thick, hard, and elevated, you likely have a hypertrophic scar or keloid.
Also known as raised scars, these "knots" of skin tissue are caused by excess collagen.
Fortunately, there are many effective options for removing raised scars, including:
You may have heard the terms "hypertrophic scar" and "keloid" used interchangeably before.
However, they are not the same!
Keloids and hypertrophic scars are so similar that even doctors often can't tell the difference.
Both have a lumpy texture, appear discolored (red to pink), and may feel itchy or painful.
The key difference is that keloids tend to grow beyond the original wound.
Keloids also do not regress on their own. Hypertrophic scars, on the other hand, may disappear by itself within 1-2 years of the initial injury.
In addition, some individuals are genetically predisposed to developing keloids. Extra caution should be taken in these cases due to the higher risk of keloid recurrence.
Here's a summary of hypertrophic scars vs. keloids (20):
In 2014, the international advisory panel on scar management provided updated clinical recommendations on hypertrophic scar treatment. (21)
First-Line Treatments
The first-line treatment for hypertrophic scars is silicone gels or sheets. These are applied directly onto the scar for 2 months.
If there are no results, the panel then recommends intralesional corticosteroid injections (repeated monthly). This is a simple in-office procedure done by your dermatologist.
Second-Line Treatments
If there's still no progress, you may wish to consider laser treatments such as pulsed dye lasers and fractional CO2 lasers. These help remove scar tissue and encourage new collagen growth.
As a last resort, you may consider surgical removal. According to the panel, surgical intervention can relieve tension in the scar, a major factor in its development. (19)
The international advisory panel also provided updated guidelines on keloid treatment.
First-Line Treatments
The first-line treatment for keloids is silicone gels or sheets plus corticosteroid injections (repeated monthly).
If there's no improvement after 8-12 weeks, the panel then recommends 5-fluorouracil in combination with corticosteroid injections.
Second-Line Treatments
If there's still no progress, laser therapy and surgical excision can be considered.
You should be aware that there's a high risk of keloid recurrence following surgery.
Silicone gels and sheets have been a mainstay of scar management since the 1980s. (3)
They are used to treat mild cases of raised scars and often paired with corticosteroid injections or surgical excision.
How It Works
Researchers believe silicone products work by hydrating and protecting the scar tissue. This helps prevent skin dehydration which can trigger excess collagen production. (22)
Clinical Evidence
In a 2017 review of 20 clinical trials, researchers noted that silicone gels and sheets were effective at preventing scars and reducing scar thickness. (23)
Silicone Gels
Silicone gels are convenient, dry quickly, and better suited for scars on the face.
You should apply silicone gels twice a day for at least 2 months.
RELATED:
Silicone Sheets
Silicone sheets are pre-shaped strips that work well for body scars.
You should wear silicone sheets for at least 12 hours a day for 2 months. (3)
After each use, the sheet must be rinsed and left out to dry (a bit inconvenient).
Verdict
Overall, silicone gels and sheets are highly recommended for all types of raised scars.
PROS
CONS
Mederma is a popular scar gel that uses onion extract (allium cepa).
How It Works
Studies show that onion extract can reduce fibroblast activity (cells that produce collagen). (24)
Onion extract also contains quercetin, a plant flavonoid that may inhibit collagen growth. (25)
By reducing collagen levels, onion extract helps prevent new scars and flatten existing ones. It can also reduce scar discoloration.
Clinical Evidence
The clinical evidence, however, is mixed:
Verdict
Overall, Mederma is an affordable option for preventing and treating raised scars.
PROS
CONS
Intralesional corticosteroid injections (also called cortisone shots or steroid injections) have been used for acne scar treatment since the 1960s. (3)
Today, it remains one of the most effective options for raised scars.
Personally, I've had great success with it for my hypertrophic scars and keloids.
One advantage of corticosteroids is that it's injected directly into the scar tissue. This makes it much more potent at reducing scar height and discoloration.
How It Works
Researchers believe corticosteroids have anti-inflammatory properties that help "turn off" overactive wound healing signals which trigger collagen growth. (3)
This may explain why it can flatten hypertrophic scars and prevent keloid recurrence.
Studies on corticosteroid injections indicate a variable success rate of 50-100%. (3)
About the Procedure
Steroid injections are a quick in-office procedure done by your dermatologist.
Results typically require 2-3 injections (repeated monthly) but may take up to 6 months or more for larger scars.
Side effects include temporary pain and discomfort. Atrophy is a concern but can be mitigated through lower dose injections over multiple sessions.
Here's a demonstration of a corticosteroid injection by Dr. Ho Rui Ming.
Cost of Corticosteroid Injections
Prices range from $50 to $100 per session.
Verdict
Corticosteroid injections are an effective and affordable option for raised scars.
PROS
CONS
5-FU is a medication traditionally used to treat cancer. Recently, however, it's been successfully used for recurring hypertrophic scars and keloids.
According to the international advisory panel, 5-FU injections may be considered when scars are unresponsive to traditional therapies. (19)
How It Works
Researchers have found that chemotherapeutic drugs like 5-FU can disrupt fibroblast activity, which reduces collagen production. (27)
This may explain why 5-FU injections can stop keloids from growing larger.
In cases of recurrent keloids, the panel recommends 5-FU injections in combination with corticosteroid injections.
Verdict
5-FU injections are a promising alternative for treating recurring keloids.
PROS
CONS
Lasers can also be used to remove scar tissue and encourage new collagen growth.
How It Works
Lasers used heat energy to destroy scarred collagen and stimulate cell repair.
Most lasers today are fractional lasers, where the laser beam is split into thousands of microscopic treatment zones.
The advantage of this design is that it leaves the surrounding skin intact. This results in fewer side effects and faster recovery times.
About the Procedure
Fractional CO2 lasers and pulsed dye lasers are both recommended for raised scars.
Several sessions are generally required and side effects are usually minimal.
Verdict
Laser treatments are an effective but expensive option for raised scars.
PROS
CONS
As a last resort, hypertrophic scars and keloids may be removed through surgery.
According to the panel, surgical intervention can relieve tension, a major factor in scar development. (19)
It's really important to note that keloids have a high chance of returning after surgical removal.
To prevent keloid recurrence, the panel recommends adjunctive therapies, such as:
Speak with your dermatologist to determine if surgery is suitable for you.
Verdict
Surgical excision should be considered as a last resort due to potential keloid recurrence.
PROS
CONS
Supplemental treatments for raised scars include:
CHAPTER 7:
Hyperpigmentation (a.k.a. dark spots) is very common when a pimple leaves town.
Fortunately, these are not acne scars.
Post-acne marks like dark spots usually go away on their own. If you want to speed up the process, you can try:
Dark spots are caused by excess melanin, a pigment in your skin that determines your skin color and shields you from harmful UV rays.
Melanin is produced by cells called melanocytes.
When your body is under attack by free radicals from UV rays, pollution, and other sources, melanocytes respond by creating more melanin.
That's because melanin has antioxidant properties that allow it to neutralize free radicals.
This is also why you get "tanned" from spending time in the sun.
Now, back to acne.
When your skin is irritated and inflamed from fighting acne, it may cause your melanocytes to create extra melanin as well.
This results in the dark spots and brown marks commonly seen after acne.
Vitamin C does amazing things for your skin.
It can help reduce the appearance of hyperpigmentation and uneven skin tone.
How It Works
Remember how hyperpigmentation is caused by excess melanin?
Well, vitamin C is clinically proven to slow down melanin production. (29)
It does this by inhibiting an enzyme called tyrosinase (involved in producing melanin). This helps reverse dark spots and brighten your overall skin tone.
But that's not all.
Vitamin C also promotes collagen formation. (29)
It influences gene expression and provides essential inputs to collagen production. This can help improve the texture of atrophic scars like boxcar and rolling scars.
Finally, vitamin C protects our skin from sun damage.
It has antioxidant properties that prevent UV rays from damaging our skin cells. (29)
UV rays are known to cause sunburn, dark spots, and skin cancer. (30)
Look For:
RELATED:
PROS
CONS
Retinol is another excellent ingredient for hyperpigmentation.
It's the strongest type of retinoid (class of vitamin A derivatives) available in OTC products.
How It Works
Similar to vitamin C, retinol reduces melanin production by inhibiting tyrosinase. This helps fade post-acne marks and troublesome dark spots. (31)
Retinol also increases cell turnover. This means dead skin cells naturally fall off faster to reveal smoother and brighter skin. (31)
PROS
CONS
There are many skin brightening creams with active ingredients that target hyperpigmentation.
Look for some of these clinically-proven ingredients:
RELATED:
PROS
CONS
CHAPTER 8:
No matter how good the treatment, you can never completely eliminate an acne scar.
Scars will always be slightly different in texture or color from the original skin.
So the best strategy is to prevent acne scars in the first place!
Here are some tips on doing just that.
Here are some of my top tips on preventing acne scars.
Aggressively Treat Cystic Acne
One of my regrets as a teenager is not proactively treating my cystic acne sooner.
Had I done so, I'd have avoided most of the acne scars that I have today.
So make sure to aggressively treat cystic acne early on and you'll save yourself lots of pain and headaches in the future!
Here are my go-to products for treating pimples and cysts:
If you find that topical treatments are not enough, speak to your dermatologist about additional options for severe acne (such as Accutane). You may also wish to visit an esthetician or clinic that has specialized in acne treatment (such as this one).
Sun Protection
Try to make it a habit of applying sunscreen before heading outside.
Even on cloudy days, there can still be significant UV rays that penetrate the atmosphere.
Avoid Picking Pimples
Unless you know what you're doing, don't pick at inflamed pimples and cysts!
You're more likely to aggravate the problem and increase the chance of acne scarring.
Drink LOTS of Water!
Hydration is often overlooked when it comes to acne scars.
Water is absolutely essential for healthy skin and normal wound healing.
So drink lots of water and also keep your skin hydrated with lotions and moisturizers!
CHAPTER 9:
In this final chapter, we address some of the most common questions on acne scars.
Acne scars are damaged skin tissue caused by inflammatory acne.
They can be pitted, indented, or depressed, as with atrophic scars like ice pick scars, boxcar scars, and rolling scars.
Or they can be hard, lumpy, and elevated, as with raised scars like hypertrophic scars and keloids.
For more information, see Chapter 1.
Unfortunately, there's no overnight "quick-fix" for acne scars. That's just the truth.
The best thing you can do is learn more about acne scars and the available treatment options.
Then visit your dermatologist or other medical professional to decide on a treatment plan.
You can start right here with this definitive guide to acne scar treatment!
Acne scars are caused by chronic inflammation that destroys healthy skin tissue.
This is usually associated with severe and prolonged cystic acne.
For more information, see Chapter 1.
There's a lot of interest in using natural remedies for acne scars.
This include products like aloe vera, coconut oil, shea butter, and more.
In general, there isn't much clinical evidence yet to support or refute using natural remedies for acne scars.
If you want to see a science-based review of these natural remedies, let me know!
If you want to prevent acne scars, it's important to aggressively treat cystic acne with topical treatments like salicylic acid, benzoyl peroxide, and sulfur.
If your acne is unresponsive to traditional treatments, speak to your dermatologist about additional options (including Accutane).
For more tips, see Chapter 8.
There are many products that claim to conceal acne scars, for those days when you want to look your best and not have to worry about them.
Acne scar concealers don't do anything to help the scar itself as it merely tries to camouflage the appearance of the scar.
Dermaflage is a well-known brand of acne scar concealers.
I know about this one all too well.
Acne scars on the chest are often keloids that appear spontaneously. This is due to the high tension in the upper chest (presternum) area.
Corticosteroid injections plus silicone gels are very effective for flattening keloids on the chest.
For more information, see Chapter 6.
The answer is it depends.
Mild cases of atrophic and hypertrophic scars may go away on their own in 6 months to a year as your skin repairs itself and new collagen is deposited.
On the other hand, severe cases of acne scars like deep ice pick scars, widespread boxcar or rolling scars, and keloids are more difficult to treat.
These will not subside on their own and can benefit from professional treatment under a qualified medical professional.