The 10 Best Scar Gels 2020 (+Before/After Pics)

|

Are you looking for the best scar gel? If so, you’re in the right place!

Scars often cause us tremendous anxiety and stress, especially ones on our face. 

I’ve had acne scars for many years (and still do) and have tried my fair share of scar gels, including brands like Mederma and ScarAway.

ⓘ In this post, I’ll help you find the right scar gel for your needs and budget!

RELATED:

What Are The Best Scar Gels?

Here are my top picks for the best scar gels:

  1. Best Overall Scar Gel: NewGel+ Advanced Silicone Gel for Scars
  2. Best Runner-Up Scar Gel: Strataderm Scar Therapy Gel
  3. Best Budget Scar Gel: ScarAway Silicone Scar Gel
  4. Best Value for Money: Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel
  5. Best for Surgery Scars: Skinmedica Scar Recovery Gel
  6. Best for Optimal Wound Recovery: Kate Somerville D-Scar® Scar Diminishing Serum
  7. Best for Skin Redness: SkinCeuticals Phyto Corrective Gel
  8. Best for Acne Scars: Murad InvisiScar Resurfacing Treatment
  9. Best for Acne Marks: Murad Post-Acne Spot Lightening Gel
  10. Best for Sun Protection: BioCorneum Advanced Scar Treatment With SPF 30

1. Best Overall Scar Gel: NewGel+ Advanced Silicone Gel for Scars

Summary: NewGel+ is my #1 pick for an effective and affordable silicone gel for your scars. 🤗

Best For: Hypertrophic Scars, Keloids, Acne Scars, and Scars from Surgery, Injury, Burns, etc.

Key Ingredients: 100% Silicone Gel

Get It @ Amazon

NewGel+ Advanced Silicone Gel for Scars
  • Save

NewGel+ is a great option for all types of scars, including keloids, hypertrophic scars, burn marks, and post-surgical scars. The ingredients are very simple:

  • Polymerized Siloxanes: silicone is recommended by the International Panel on Scar Management as first-line therapy for hypertrophic scars and keloids
  • Vitamin E: helps moisturize & soften your scars while also providing antioxidant benefits

Customer reviews of NewGel+ have been very positive. Some of the comments include:

  • Flattened raised scars
  • Faded surgical scars
  • Reduced scar redness
  • More even skin tone
  • Smooth texture and dries quickly

As with any silicone gel, you should apply this product twice a day to maintain continuous coverage on your scar. Thankfully, NewGel+ has a smooth and lightweight texture that makes it easy to wear for long periods of time.

2. Best Runner-Up Scar Gel: Strataderm Scar Therapy Gel

Summary: Strataderm is my next top choice for a medical grade silicone gel for scar treatment.

Best For: Existing Hypertrophic Scars

Key Ingredients: 100% Silicone Gel

Get It @ Amazon

Strataderm Scar Therapy Gel
  • Save

Text

3. Best Budget Scar Gel: ScarAway Silicone Scar Gel

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Walgreens, Amazon

ScarAway Silicone Scar Gel
  • Save

Scaraway is another household name in scar treatment that is often recommended by dermatologists and surgeons. I’ve used many of their silicone scar sheets and gels in the past for my keloid scars.

What makes this scar gel unique is the roller ball applicator at the end of the tube. You use this to gently massage the gel into the scar tissue area. 

Massage therapy can be an effective technique for breaking up scar tissue and encouraging better alignment of collagen fibers. This technique is often used by physical therapists.

4. Best Value for Money: Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Amazon

Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel
  • Save

Kelo-Cote is a popular brand of high quality silicone gels designed to reduce the appearance of both hypertrophic scars and keloids. The main ingredients are:

  • Polysiloxanes (Silicone Gel)
  • Silicon Dioxide (Protective Layer)

Kelo-Cote features a silicone technology known as Advanced Silliclear Complex. This blend of cross-linking silicones bonds tightly with your skin for 24-hour scar coverage and protection.

Once applied, Kelo-Cote forms a thin, flexible, and breathable gel layer that helps soften and flatten the underlying scar tissue to restore normal and healthy-looking skin.

Customer reviews have been very strong and many people noticed improvements in their keloid and post-surgical scars.

5. Best for Surgery Scars: Skinmedica Scar Recovery Gel

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Amazon, Dermstore

Skinmedica Scar Recovery Gel
  • Save

A respected name in dermatology, SkinMedica’s Scar Recovery Gel helps minimize and reduce the appearance of red and pink scars (very common after cosmetic procedures like laser resurfacing).

This scar gel features the key ingredient Centelline, which is a synergistic blend of:

Many customers noted that this product significantly improved their surgery scars and was available at a lower price on Amazon than at their dermatologist’s office.

SkinMedica Scar Recovery Gel should be used twice a day, both in the morning and evening, and for at least 3 months on new scars and up to 6 months on old scars.

6. Best for Optimal Wound Recovery: Kate Somerville D-Scar® Scar Diminishing Serum

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Ulta Beauty, Sephora

Kate Somerville D-Scar Scar Diminishing Serum
  • Save

Text

7. Best for Skin Redness: SkinCeuticals Phyto Corrective Gel

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Skinceuticals, Dermstore

SkinCeuticals Phyto Corrective Gel
  • Save

Text

8. Best for Acne Scars: Murad InvisiScar Resurfacing Treatment

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Sephora, Amazon

Murad InvisiScar Resurfacing Treatment
  • Save

Text

9. Best for Acne Marks: Murad Post-Acne Spot Lightening Gel

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Sephora, Amazon

Murad Post-Acne Spot Lightening Gel
  • Save

Text

10. Best for Sun Protection: BioCorneum Advanced Scar Treatment With SPF 30

Summary: The CANE+AUSTIN 20% Miracle Pad+ provides similar results to professional in-office peels for a fraction of the cost. ?

Best For: Dark Spots, Uneven Tone

Key Ingredients: 20% Glycolic Acid

Get It @ Amazon

BioCorneum Advanced Scar Treatment With SPF 30
  • Save

BioCorneum combines the benefits of a silicone scar gel with the protection of a sunscreen. 

Sun protection is very important during scar treatment to prevent further discoloration or hyperpigmentation. Scar tissue is particularly sensitive to UV damage from the sun.

If you’re someone who typically forgets to apply sunscreen, this product will be convenient for you!

Many customers noticed steady improvements in post-surgical scars within a few months. Some customers were referred to BioCorneum by their doctor or dermatologist.

Unfortunately, this product is fairly expensive compared to other silicone scar gels.

Copy link