Find the best silicone scar sheets for your skin type, skin condition, and budget, plus get all my tips on scar treatment in this article. Overall, my top recommendation is ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets.
Silicone sheets have been used for decades to treat and prevent hypertrophic scars and keloids from surgical procedures, injuries & wounds, cuts & bruises, burns, and severe acne.
That's because silicone has been clinically proven to improve your scar appearance and also alleviate common symptoms like redness, itching, and discomfort. 🤗
The International Advisory Panel on Scar Management, a group of medical professionals, recommends silicone sheets for treating raised scars (source: Dermatologic Surgery, 2014).
I've personally used silicone sheets like ScarAway with great results in combination with in-office treatments like corticosteroid injections.
Keep reading to see my incredible before/after photos!
Here are the best silicone scar sheets (and best silicone sheets for scars):
My top recommendation is ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets.
It's a brand that I've used many times in the past for my own scars and I consider them as one of the best silicone sheets for keloids and hypertrophic scars.
ScarAway was recommended to me by a specialist doctor after I had corticosteroid injections to flatten my raised scars. He said ScarAway could help soften my scars, reduce redness, and might even prevent them from coming back (a growing problem with keloids, pun intended).
By the way, if you're struggling with keloids or hypertrophic scars, especially ones that continue to get bigger over time, I recommend talking to your doctor about corticosteroid injections.
It was the most effective therapy that I've tried for my chest keloids and hypertrophic scars, and it's reasonably affordable, too (and I've tried everything from Mederma, Bio-Oil, Palmer's, Vaseline, creams, pressure therapy, Chinese traditional medicine, you get the picture 🤔).
Anyways, I used ScarAway in between each injection session and for months after my last treatment (which was two years ago).
Today, I continue to use a silicone gel to maintain my results and flatten any new scars (unfortunately, like many people, I am prone to developing keloids 😑; research suggests keloids are influenced by our genetics, including a tendency to produce excess collagen during the inflammatory phase of wound healing).
I think pictures tell a thousand words. Here's my facial hypertrophic scars back in May 2015:
And now, here's my scars after many years of scar treatment, including corticosteroid injections (around 6-8 shots with 1-3 months in between), and dozens of scar products including Mederma, Bio-Oil, ScarAway, NewGel+, Kelo-Cote, (you name it and I've tried it):
As you can see, my facial hypertrophic scars (some were also keloids) have diminished significantly in the last 5 years, thanks to corticosteroid injections and silicone sheets/gels. 👏
Here's some photos that show the progression of my chest keloids as well, from 2015 to 2020:
From 2016-2018, I received corticosteroid injections from my dermatologist for my chest keloids (which was very painful).
However, this produced a dramatic improvement in these scars, flattening them out and reducing the redness to the point where some are barely noticeable.
I used ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets during and after my treatment to maintain these results and help prevent the recurrence of any hypertrophic scars or keloids.
These days, I'm testing different silicone gel brands (ScarAway, NewGel+, Kelo-Cote, Strataderm) but might go back to the sheets if I decide to get another round of corticosteroid injections.
Now, you might be asking yourself at this point, "Is ScarAway suitable for my scar?"
As long as your scar is "closed", meaning your skin is not severely damaged or oozing out fluids, you should be able to use ScarAway to minimize post-surgery scar formation and help flatten existing scars. Of course, talk to your doctor if you have any concerns. 👨⚕️
Finally, here are the product specifications for ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets:
My Verdict: ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets is my #1 pick for an effective and affordable solution for your hypertrophic scars and keloids, especially when combined with a professional treatment like corticosteroid injections. ScarAway is suitable for all types of scars, including small-to-medium scars from surgery, injury, trauma, burns, keloids, and acne. 👍Shop Now
If you search for "silicone sheets" on Amazon.com, you'll no doubt come across this popular brand of silicone products: Aroamas.
With over 3,000+ reviews and a whopping 4.7 out of 5.0, it must be pretty good, right?
Well, I haven't personally used Aroamas products before, but I did notice a couple of red flags while browsing their Amazon product page and doing research on this company.
Based on their website, Aroamas is what you would call an Amazon dropshipper.
In other words, a company that sells a wide variety of products on Amazon (usually exclusively) and contracts with a third-party manufacturer to create the products.
For example, Aroamas also sells things like wart removers, nail fungus pens, and nicotine patches. Here's a screenshot of their website:
In my opinion, the main problem with most dropshipping brands is the product quality.
Think about it: since this company is a "middle man" between the manufacturer and consumer (although they do run their own marketing and advertising), they have very little control over the manufacturing quality and are incentivized to use the lowest cost manufacturer to maintain a profit margin (and cover expenses like listing on Amazon, advertising, shipping, etc.).
Now, I don't want to paint all dropshippers with a broad brush, but generally speaking, there are tons of these brands on Amazon and some of them engage in less-than-ethical behavior when it comes to manipulating user ratings, creating fake reviews, or encouraging positive reviews (such as in exchange for a free product or full refund).
In this case, I find the rating distribution of Aroamas very questionable:
But consider the fact that ScarAway and Mederma (two of the most popular scar products) managed to get only 50-65% ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ with a much higher percentage of negative reviews (~20-30% in the 1-, 2-, or 3-star buckets) compared to Aroamas (only 6% in the same buckets):
In other words, if we take the rating distribution at face value, it means Aroamas is a vastly superior product to ScarAway and Mederma with 85% ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ compared to 53% and 65%, respectively.
To understand how ridiculous this is, I found a product with a similar star rating distribution: Duracell's high-quality AAA batteries with 88% ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐. Something just isn't right here.
To be clear, I've got nothing against Aroamas but I find this rating distribution very suspicious.
My Verdict: Aroamas is a bestseller with 3,000+ ratings and a whopping 85% ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ ratings. Personally, I'm skeptical of the rating distribution. Moreover, at the current price (~$28 for 8 sheets), ScarAway is actually cheaper (~$16 for 12 sheets).Shop Now
If you need a silicone tape for scars, I highly recommend CicaTape by CicaSolution.
This generous-sized silicone tape measures 1.57" by 59.0" with 30 individual 2" pieces that can be easily torn off without scissors. You can use multiple pieces to cover up larger scars.
This product is commonly used in hospitals to attach IV lines to a patient's skin which means it needs to have very strong adhesive properties.
CicaTape is the perfect solution for scars that require more flexibility, like on the hands, fingers, elbows, knees, neck, and feet. That's because CicaTape is very adhesive and doesn't fall off or roll up as easily as some other brands. 🙏
Similar to ScarAway and Aroamas, each sheet can be washed, air dryed, and reused for a few days or until the sheet can no longer stick to your skin properly.
My Verdict: CicaTape is an excellent silicone tape for any scars that require more flexibility. It has good reviews and is an affordable price for a generous length (1.57" by 59.0"). 🤗Shop Now
For new Moms, ScarAway has designed a special silicone sheet just for you. ❤️
These silicone strips are longer than normal ScarAway sheets to cover incision marks left behind by Cesarean delivery. One strip should be able to completely cover a C-section scar.
In addition, these silicone strips are more comfortable to wear with ultra-thin breathable fabric that can be gently removed without pulling or tugging on your sensitive skin.
With continuous use (alternate between 2 strips for the day and night), this product can minimize abnormal scar formation like hypertrophic scars & keloids and fade incision marks.
The silicone sheets also reduce redness, itching, and discomfort. 😍
The main problem with longer silicone sheets is that they tend to "bunch up", which reduces the adhesion and effectiveness of the product.
To make the most of every silicone sheet, wash it after each use and use your thumbs to massage and stretch out the product (this helps it absorb moisture and retain its adhesiveness).
My Verdict: ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets for C-Section are specially designed for new Moms with ultra-thin & breathable fabric and 100% silicone to help fade C-section scars. ❤️Shop Now
Embrace Scar Therapy is another well-known brand of silicone sheets.
The company was founded by a group of plastic surgeons at Stanford University and has made partnerships with celebrities like Serena Williams to advertise their products.
According to Embrace Scar Therapy, the company's silicone sheets incorporate:
However, if you check out any of Embrace's silicone sheets on Amazon, you'll notice that the reviews have been overwhelming negative with 57% of ratings in the 1-, 2-, or 3-star buckets.
After reading some of these reviews, it seems most people complained about the product not adhering to their skin, leaving behind blisters or causing skin irritation, and the high price.
The problem, though, is that the Tummy Tuck product is "lumped in" with other Embrace products like the Small, Medium, Large, and X-Large silicone sheets (many Amazon sellers do this to make it seem like they have a large number of reviews).
In other words, we don't know the rating for the Tummy Tuck version on its own. There is one way that's slightly complicated: go to "see all customer reviews", "see all reviews from the United States", then under the "Filter By" boxes, click on "All Formats", and select "Show only reviews for ....".
This will show you only the reviews from people who actually bought the Tummy Tuck kit.
Anyways, here's the product specifications for Embrace Active Scar Defense for Tummy Tuck Scars:
Now, it's really important that you follow the instructions carefully and apply the silicone sheet to a clean skin surface with no oils, creams, or ointments (watch the Embrace video here).
My Verdict: If you have tummy tuck scars or are planning to undergo a tummy tuck procedure, the Embrace Active Scar Defense can help minimize scar formation and reduce scar appearance after your surgery. The main sticking point is the price (pun intended!) and a more budget-friendly alternative is the ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets Long (1.5" by 7.0").Shop Now
Speaking of which, the ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets Long is an excellent and affordable alternative to the normal version (only 1.5" by 3.0") for longer scars (this one is 1.5" by 7.0").
This includes scars from surgical incisions (like C-section and tummy tuck), cuts and bruises, and linear hypertrophic scars (which may arise following surgery, injury, burn, or natural tension).
With regular use, silicone sheets may help flatten and reduce the size of hypertrophic scars, relieve common symptoms like itching and redness, and prevent post-op scars from forming. 😀
As I mentioned in the previous section, you might want to consider ScarAway Long as a cheaper version of Embrace Active Scar Defense for Tummy Tuck Scars. You can buy 12 sheets of ScarAway for about $40 on Amazon and cover your entire tummy tuck scar with roughly 3 silicone sheets.
The most common complaint with this product is the adhesiveness, especially around the edges where some people noticed that it stopped sticking to their skin pretty quickly.
What I like to do is to rinse the silicone sheet after each use (wear about 12 hours and swap out) and use both thumbs to squeeze and stretch out the silicone side under the tap. This will make sure it's clean of any debris and skin oils that have accumulated during the day and also restores moisture to the silicone sheet which helps it retain its adhesive properties. 🤗
This will help you make the most out of each silicone sheet (and save money in the long run!).
My Verdict: If you have long scars from surgery, injury, burn, or natural tension (like chest keloids), ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheets Long are an excellent and affordable option for flattening them.Shop Now
Mepiform is a brand of medical grade silicone sheets by Mölnlycke (based in Sweden). This large silicone bandage measures 4.0" by 7.0" which makes it perfect for larger scars that would otherwise require multiple silicone sheets (often less-than-ideal for wound healing).
A large silicone bandage is also less likely to fall off or stick onto clothing since it attaches to more surface area on your skin.
You can also cut Mepiform into small sizes to fit your specific scar.
With continuous 24 hour coverage, this product helps minimize scar formation and improve the appearance of scars from knee surgery, general surgery, major wounds, and car accidents.
Overall, customer reviews of Mepiform have been very positive and it's reasonably priced given the large size of each silicone bandage (each box contains 5 in total).
My Verdict: If you have large scars from surgery, injury, or trauma, Mepiform is a great option that can cover your entire scar, promote normal wound healing, and improve scar appearance. 👍Shop Now
For breast reduction or breast lift, also known as mastopexy, these "anchor" shaped silicone strips by Epi-Derm are designed to help improve post-op recovery and minimize scars.
These silicone strips are suitable for breast reductions or breast lifts using the Anchor Pattern where incisions are made to reduce breast fat and skin tissue. (source: VeryWellHealth)
This surgical operation results in "anchor" shaped scars which these silicone strips aim to address.
My Verdict: The Epi-Derm Mastopexy Silicone Strips are a fantastic product for improving your recovery process following breast reduction or breast lift surgery using the Anchor Pattern. ⚓Shop Now
For breast reduction or breast lifts using the Lollipop Pattern (a.k.a. Lejour Augmentation Technique), you'll want to grab a pair of these silicone strips instead.
Similar to the "anchor" ones, these "lollipop" shaped silicone strips are designed to improve your post-op healing process and reduce scar appearance following breast reduction surgery.
My Verdict: The Epi-Derm Areopexy Silicone Strips are an amazing product to improve your post-op healing process following breast reduction or breast lift surgery using the Lollipop Pattern.Shop Now
Last but not least, the Pro-Sil Silicone Scar Treatment Stick is a travel-friendly silicone "chapstick" that you can bring on flights and trips or use on sensitive scars near your eyes and fingers.
Unlike silicone sheets, which can only be used on relatively flat surfaces, Pro-Sil can be applied to scars on any part of your body, including facial scars (just make sure you apply to clean, dry skin).
My Verdict: The Pro-Sil "chapstick" is a great option for both travel and sensitive scars. 👍Shop Now