When it comes to hydrating dry, flaky skin, AmLactin and Eucerin are two drugstore stalwarts. But as a skincare editor who's tried them both extensively, I find they each shine […]
When it comes to hydrating dry, flaky skin, AmLactin and Eucerin are two drugstore stalwarts. But as a skincare editor who's tried them both extensively, I find they each shine depending on your specific needs.
Ingredients
AmLactin features lactic acid, an alpha hydroxy acid that exfoliates while hydrating. This helps slough off dead skin cells to reveal smoother skin below. The formulas also contain humectants like glycerin.
Eucerin relies more on emollients like shea butter and dimethicone to seal in moisture. Many products also incorporate ceramides, lipids naturally found in skin that reinforce the protective barrier against water loss.
Effectiveness
For extremely dry, cracked skin plagued by rough patches and flaking, AmLactin delivers smoothing results. The lactic acid gently exfoliates to help hydrate better than a standard lotion. It leaves skin visibly smoother and softer.
Eucerin also excels at hydrating dry skin, but works best for delicate dryness needing nourishment without exfoliation. The rich creams with ceramides repair the compromised moisture barrier and prevent future water loss. But they don't exfoliate like AmLactin.
Texture
AmLactin has a lightweight, easily absorbed lotion texture. The formulas aren't greasy but you'll notice slight tingling from the lactic acid.
Eucerin offers richer, more emollient moisturizers that provide an occlusive layer. The creams are quite nourishing but can feel heavier than AmLactin's exfoliating lotions.
Skin Types
AmLactin suits severely dry, rough skin that can tolerate gentle exfoliation. Very flaky areas need AmLactin's renewing formulas. Those with sensitivities should patch test first.
Eucerin is better for delicate dry to very dry skin needing moisture without irritation. It’s ideal for thin or easily reddened skin prone to reactivity and sensitization from too much exfoliation.
Reviews
AmLactin garners over 7,000 Amazon reviews and 4.5 stars. Fans mention the noticeable improvement in texture, softness and hydration. Some report mild irritation.
Eucerin earns 4.6 stars across over 7,000 ratings. Users love the soothing relief for dryness without greasiness or redness. But some say it’s not strong enough for severe flaking.
Pricing
Both brands are very affordable for their quality. A 20oz pump bottle of AmLactin Daily Moisturizing Lotion costs around $15. Comparable sized Eucerin Intensive Repair lotion runs about $10-12. Given their trusted results, the pricing is quite budget-friendly.
The verdict: AmLactin delivers smoothing hydration that exfoliates for ultra-dry skin. But for delicate dryness needing pure nourishment, Eucerin’s formulas hydrate without sensitization. Together, they target dryness from multiple angles.