St. Ives vs Aveeno | Which Body Lotion Is Better?

written by: Tom Qiao
last update: February 16, 2024

Oatmeal is known for its skin-calming benefits, which is why it's a key ingredient in many body lotions. As a skincare editor, two oatmeal-infused products I often get asked about […]

Oatmeal is known for its skin-calming benefits, which is why it's a key ingredient in many body lotions. As a skincare editor, two oatmeal-infused products I often get asked about are St. Ives Soothing Oatmeal & Shea Butter Lotion and Aveeno Daily Moisturizing Body Lotion. Both can hydrate dry, irritated skin but also have differences.

Ingredients

St. Ives contains colloidal oatmeal along with nourishing shea butter and olive oil. Aveeno relies on soothing colloidal oatmeal plus ceramides to restore the skin barrier and keep moisture in.

While both leverage hydrating oatmeal, St. Ives includes more emollients like shea butter for extra moisture. Aveeno focuses more on skin-natural oat extracts to calm and protect sensitive skin.

Texture

St. Ives has a rich, creamy formula that leaves skin feeling soft and supple. Aveeno absorbs more quickly but still provides long-lasting hydration thanks to skin-conditioning oils.

Soothing Ability

Both oatmeal lotions help relieve dryness and irritation. But Aveeno seems to have a slight edge when it comes to reducing inflammation, redness, and itching thanks to its concentration of colloidal oatmeal.

Fragrance

St. Ives has added fragrance that could potentially irritate some sensitive skin types. Aveeno uses minimal, fragrance-free ingredients ideal for easily irritated skin.

Price and Availability

The two are close in cost at around $6-$12 USD per 12-18oz bottle. Aveeno is occasionally pricier. Both can be found at any drug or grocery store.

Skin Type Suitability

St. Ives works well for mildly dry, sensitive skin needing hydration with a pleasant scent. Aveeno is ideal for those with eczema, psoriasis or chronic dryness requiring fragrance-free ingredients.

The Bottom Line

While both leverage the soothing power of oatmeal, Aveeno’s formulas specialize in relief for sensitive, eczema-prone skin. St. Ives offers a pleasantly scented, nourishing formula. So it depends on your skin type and preference for fragrances when choosing between these two affordable drugstore options.

For those who enjoy light fragrance, St. Ives provides great nourishing moisture with the benefits of oatmeal and shea. But for targeted relief of irritated, extra-sensitive skin, Aveeno's formulas with concentrated colloidal oatmeal are my top pick.

Article written by Tom Qiao
Tom is the founder and editor of TheDermDetective.com where he applies his decades of personal experience with skincare problems like acne and acne scarring to provide readers with practical advice and product recommendations.

Related Posts

Subscribe.

Skin mysteries by email.
Subscribe - Post Sidebar

Join Our Email Newsletter.

Get the latest skincare science in your inbox.
Subscribe - Home, Pages, Posts

Related Posts

© 2024 YTQ Digital Inc.
Share via
Copy link