As a skincare editor who's tested countless anti-aging creams, Olay and Eucerin both stand out for offering retinol at an affordable price point. However, after trying their night creams extensively, […]
As a skincare editor who's tested countless anti-aging creams, Olay and Eucerin both stand out for offering retinol at an affordable price point. However, after trying their night creams extensively, I've found some notable differences between these drugstore favorites.
Olay combines pure retinoid with vitamins B3 and E to gently deliver skin-smoothing results overnight. The formulas also contain hydrators like glycerin.
Eucerin focuses solely on encapsulated retinol, which gradually releases over time to minimize irritation. The creams also incorporate shea butter and emollients to moisturize while retinol works.
For reducing the look of fine lines, wrinkles, and uneven texture with continued use, both creams are effective. Olay adds antioxidants to combat aging free radicals, while Eucerin soothes with rich moisturizers as retinol renews.
Those with very dry skin may find Eucerin's night cream more nourishing, thanks to ingredients like shea butter that provide extra moisture as retinol exfoliates. Olay still smooths without over-drying.
Olay features a lightweight gel-cream texture that absorbs quickly without any greasy residue. Eucerin has a richer, more emollient feel that leaves skin looking more hydrated overnight.
Oily or acne-prone skin may prefer Olay's less pore-clogging texture. Eucerin can feel heavy on the skin, potentially leading to breakouts for some. But dry skin drinks up the extra moisture.
Olay Retinol 24 is suitable for most skin types, including oily and sensitive, though they recommend starting with only a few nights per week.
Eucerin's cream is better for dry and mature skin needing intense nourishment along with their retinol. Those prone to clogs or breakouts should opt for Olay.
Olay earns 4.5 stars on Amazon from over 3,500 reviewers who mention both smoothing and gentle properties. Some experience peeling.
Eucerin is rated 4.4 stars by 600+ users who love the hydration but warn the fragrance may irritate sensitive skin.
Olay retails for around $28 for a 1.7 oz bottle while Eucerin costs approximately $15 for 1.7 oz. Given Eucerin's quality ingredients, it delivers excellent value. But Olay has the edge for most skin types.
The verdict: those with dry skin will reap the most anti-aging benefits from Eucerin’s nourishing night cream. But for a retinol suitable across skin types, Olay takes the lead with light yet effective formulas. Both transform skin overnight on a budget!
Tom is the founder and editor of TheDermDetective.com where he applies his decades of personal experience with skincare problems like acne and acne scarring to provide readers with practical advice and product recommendations.